Showing posts with label three and a half star films. Show all posts
Showing posts with label three and a half star films. Show all posts

24.5.07

DIRECTOR - VICTOR GAVIRIA: La Vendedora de Rosas / Rodrigo D.

La Vendedora de Rosas: llll
Rodrigo D: llll.5

Victor Gaviria is one of the most significant directors from Latin America. Given his style of film it is not surprising that he still remains largely unknown outside of the Latin American independent film culture. But since the release of his first major movie, Rodrigo D. - No Futuro, he has been busy archiving awards from film festivals across Latin America, Europe, and North America. He has masterfully used the style of Cinema Verite to grant his audiences an exclusive and intimate look into the lives of Colombian youth, while making two of the very best films in the country's history. Granted, the country has a relatively limited film history, but Gaviria's films reflect the legacy of other Latin American filmmakers such as the Brazilian Hector Babenco with "Pixote" and Mexican Luis Bunuel with "Los Olvidados", and deserve greater international attention not just for their critical social themes but also for their cinematic style. Gaviria has structured his films so that every single character, dialogue and scene feels absolutely real. To capture the reality of street life in Medellin he gathers actual teenagers who talk, feel and live virtually the same experiences of the characters they are performing. In hindsight, the correlation of the "actors" with their roles proved prophetic. A few years after each of the movies was released many of the actors were killed by street violence, in prison, or in a life of reckless crime and drug abuse. While their lives changed little with the production of the movies (with the exception of additional cash and some limited press), the movies remain as one of the most honest and captivating portraits of street life in Latin America.
Rodrigo D. explores the life of low-income teenage boys as they struggle to find their place in the world while surrounded by ever-present violence and presented no viable options. Punk Rock provides the main source of self-expression. The distant dream of being a musician also serves as a string of hope. But ultimately they live without regard for tomorrow, too many of their friends and brothers have died to worry about growing old. But the utter realism of the film manages to not only capture the challenges of their lives but also the glimpses of hope between the creaks.
La Vendedora de Rosas (the Rose Seller) focuses instead on the life of teenage girls and a whole new set of problems arise. These films stand in contrast to the Brazilian film "Cidade de Deus" (City of God), in the virtually invisible hand of the director and the exceptional sincerity of the performances.
His most recent film takes a different subject, as it explores the life of an engineer who becomes involved in Colombia's drug industry to make money fast and becomes shaken by it beyond what he could have imagined. Tyler

30.11.06

THE FOUNTAIN


Kat and Tyler: lll.5

The Fountain juxtaposes three stories, which follow the powerful romance between the two main characters, performed by Hugh Jackman and Rachel Weisz, across time periods 500 years apart. The first relates the mission of Conquistador Tomas, sent by the beautiful queen Isabel to discover the Fountain of Youth, lost somewhere in the Mayan Empire since it was vanished by God from Eden. Upon finding the Fountain, embodied in a mysterious tree, Tomas may take the hand of the Queen in eternal marriage. In the second story, Tommy begins to discover the medical secrets of a long forgotten Central American tree as his wife dies slowly due to an untreatable tumor. Five centuries later, Tom finds himself travelling through open space with a tree that allows him to extend his life indefinitely, despite lacking food or water.

Each one of these stories is charged with remarkeably honest performances, subtle details and stunning imagery. Together, they create an insightful tapestry of the meaning of loss, mourning, and the hypothetical of eternal life. It is then unfortunate that the interconnections between the stories are unclear and generally convoluted, ultimately weakening the message and impact of the movie. The combination of three different genres, historical fiction, drama and futuristic sci-fi, does not produce the expected results, but instead left me confused. There is not a clear understanding of which is the central story and despite careful observation it is still difficult to assess the connections between Hugh Jackman's characters. As the movie progresses it appears that the first story with which the movie started may in fact be a fictional narration by Tommy's wife Izi, as she is dying of a tumor. This sems hard to believe given the vivid character of the 16th century story and the centrality given to it, but more so because it does not represent the experiences of Izi, who finds herself acepting the inevitability of death while Queen Isabel is sending the Conquistador to save Spain from the chains of death. Additionally, it is not completely clear whether the astronaut is the same man as the doctor, reaching the last moments of his existence after five centuries alive, or whether it is another fictional creation, this time in the mind of Tommy as he tries to cope with mortality.

The Fountain is a beautifull collection of images that shows Jackman's quest to save the woman that he loves. I particularly enjoyed the relationship between the two characters, expressed by subtle details, such as morning kisses, gentle baths and loving looks, as well as vivid colors and moving performaces. Weisz is remarkable in this movie, particularly in how she expresses emotions without uttering a word. She is absolutely breathtaking. Even more central is Hugh Jackman, who succeeds in providing his most honest and thoughtful performance to date.

The result is a movie that builds high expectations and hypnotizes the audience with breathtaking images, remarkable acting and thoughtful direction, but ultimately fails to deliver on its promises of being a classic film. Contrary to Roger Ebert's suggestion in his review of this movie, it does not reach the level of much better crafted works such as Magnolia or Babel.

Most importanly, it fails at providing a unique message on the profound issues it attempts to address. It is difficult to fully connect with the main character's evolution, because it feels unreal, rushed and unpolished. While it successfully conveys the fear of losing what is most dear, in this case beautfifully embodied by Weisz, it then fails at demonstrating how to let go by giving mixed signals about what may come next. The movie loosely interchanges the concept of living eternally after death and of an absolute void. While thre are hints at religion, especially from the innitial quest for the Fountain of Youth, it is also unclear whether a supernatural force has a role in their lives or not. The result is understandably frustrating, particularly from a philosophical standpoint.

Despite its frustrating shortcomings, many of which have been made clear by critics across the world, The Fountain is an ambitious cinematic effort, which is ultimately moving, insightful and enjoyable.

- Kat and Tyler

28.11.06

American Splendor

Kat: lll.5
Tyler: llll

The Departed

Kat: lll
Tyler: lll.5

18.11.06

BORAT (Counterargument)
Tyler: lll.5

There are few occasions when Kat and I substantially disagree on a movie, and this is one of them, hence I will present my counterargument:

Suddenly Borat, a British comedian turned Kazak reporter, began appearing on tv screens everywhere, from Jon Stewart to CNN. When it finally arrived at the theaters it made an explossive amount of money. Shows were sold out throughout DC and the buzz was unstoppable. To begin with, my expectations before entering the movie were virtually none. I expected an insensitive and profoundly offensive attack on culture and intelligence. To be honest, my original expectations were not fully dissappointed. However, there is still much more to Borat than may meet the eye. To begin with, even Kat was cracking up for most of the movie, with an almost non-stop expression of WTF and "this can not be happening". A lot of the movie is simply hilarious. While those moments were scattered, they were able to remain inprinted and Borat's commited quest to his virgin in L.A., Pamela Anderson, gave the movie a clear direction and kept the audience hooked. While Borat may not necessarily be the classic of our generation that critics like Rolling Stone's Peter Travers make it out to be, there is a distinct degree of dedication and ingenuity that appears all too easy at first. The best metaphor I can give is that Borat incorporates the sense of offensive, self-destructive and relentless audacity of Jackass with the critical sociopolitical wit and ingenuity of the Colbert Report. His capacity to stay in charcter in face of the most shocking experiences, and to expose the sexist, racist, jew-hating, destructive and absurd core of America is devastatingly funny... and painfully revealing. In oppose to Kat, what I found most central about the movie were not its senseless fart jokes but the shoking realities revealed. To respond to the claim of Borat's insensitivity, sexism, discrimination, and every other profoundly politically incorrect thing he does, I can say the following: throughout the entire movie, Borat flirts with very limits of political incorrectedness, leaving the audience with an almost constant reaction of OMG and WTF. However, the most shocking comments do not come from Borat but from those around him. The list is mindblowingly absurd coments is endless and should not be ruined for you. At the end, what Borat exposes is not the irreconciliable gap between Americans and this alleged Kazak. Regretably, it is a somewhat distorted, yet nonetheless excruitiatingly enlightening reflection of an America all to often ignored. An America taken for granted on a daily basis until it is painted in a parody of another country, one perceived as an obscure, suspicious and probably terrorist backward-country lost on the map somewhere between oil and terrorism. P.S. I don't want to imagine how offensive this movie may seen to many patriotic (and righteously so) Kazaks. For them, I'm trully sorry. I'm sorry your country had to be used and abused for the sake of a critical comedy on the US and A. (Note: for those who may be interested, this former member of the USSR is one of the largest countries in the world {the size of the entire Western Europe} and is located just south of Russia. It has a relatively stable political environment and with its many natural resources its economy is growing at a rate of almost 10%. It may help to know a little more about the country befor watching the movie to better see the parody of the whole thing.)
- Tyler Paris